Subscribe to our newsletter for new stories, tips & events. She was out riding with Kayce and Beth when her horse spooked and fell on her. I still am not clear why Beth was hated by her mom. After falling off, Evelyn says, while looking at Beth, She did this. Important to note is that in Season 5, Yellowstone subtly reveals that Jamie is five years older than Beth. Beths mom being cold af in her dying moments was fucked, but ultimately it finished the job of making Beth tougher than any man. John and Evelyn were blessed with four children, two of which are brothers and one of which is a sister. Evelyns monologue arguably sets in Beths mind that it is her against the world. My grandpa insisted immediately she get right back on her horse, because in his crazy mind, her fear would not be conquered immediately and she would never ride again. A nascent romance between Beth and Rip eventually begets a pregnancy that a distraught Beth looks to end with the help of her older brother, Jamie. Rip or Lloyd explains to someone shortly after that the horse can feel every emotion the rider has. Was there something I missed that sheds light on this? The shows board on the social media platform continues to prompt thought-provoking discussion on our favorite characters. Evelyn and her sisters are the mothers of Jamie and Jimmy. (Not an excuse, I just remember that from those flashbacks).. Y:1883 will premiere December 19, 2021 on Paramount+. My best guess is and I've said it before perhaps Evelyn and John only wanted boys instead of girls, and Evelyn resented having Beth. He was a very wise and compassionate man, and he passed down his values to his son. In one episode, during Evelyns death anniversary, Beth, struggling to cope, bathed in a trough and drank champagne to wash away her guilt. How Helen Keller Overcame the Barriers To Speech, Clocktane Octane Skin: Embodying a Timeless Style, Aldor vs. Scryers: Rogues Guide to Shattrath City, The Babyface Brothers Musical Legacy: Kevon, Melvin, and Kenneth. No, Kayce Dutton is not adopted. Youre not, though. Evelyn was bucked off her horse as Beth hesitated. Evelyn Dutton is the late wife of John Dutton and the mother of Lee, Kayce, Jamie, and Beth. Prior to her death, Beth became nervous on her horse, causing her horse to spook leading to Evelyns horse to spook too. If youre as invested in Yellowstone as we are, then you already know about Beth Duttons rocky relationship with her late mother. Her death also took a considerable toll on her children, especially Beth. The heir to the Dutton Ranch, Lee was killed by Robert Long (Monica's . Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. On March 30, 1997, Evelyn was out horse riding with children Beth and Kayce. A wildfire broke out on their ranch and Evelyn refused to leave her horses behind. Star Stable Codes (Updated) & How to Redeem Them, Who Is Bianca Rodrigues? His parents are James and Margaret Dutton. Beths mom was calling her scared and thats what killed her. Evelyn Dutton takes her last breath when John reaches her. Beth was able to escape the burning building, but she was left with severe burns on her face. Since the start of "Yellowstone," there have been so many products and posts dedicated to this character. And his status or role on the show. Kevin Costner plays John Dutton in the movie, but he is also his great aunt. After mulling over why everyone hates Jamie as much as they do (again), the Redditor moves to Beths deep emotional scarring by matriarch Evelyn Dutton. It was all that was needed for a touching moment in the finale when Beth and Rip got married. Columbia, South Carolina, United States of America, is home to an American actress namedKelsey Asbille Chow. Back then and now, Beth continues to self-medicate with abundant alcohol and cigarette use. There is no way to recover from that massive of a procedure privately. No wonder Beth is a mess.. I mean what they showed in the flashback, if that is a true representation of what happened, was a horse spooking. Her death took a toll on the family, being a traumatic experience for John and their children. The fourth season of Yellowstone is well on its way, and viewers are still none the wiser to the fate of Beth Dutton (played by Kelly Reilly) after last years staggering finale. All those boys you used to outrun and outwrestle, thats all done, Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) says after a young Beth starts her period in this EXCLUSIVE preview of a Yellowstone flashback scene from the Aug. 8 episode. While that might just be a detail for . Jamie helped Beth procure an abortion after she decided to end her pregnancies. Beth's scars may have faded even more by the time the recently confirmed season five comes around, but they will always be there to remind viewers of her traumatic journey so far. Although the actress who plays Beth Dutton is from the U.K., this does not mean her love for Montana isn't real. When Beths riding scares the horse, it has a domino effect. Its no secret that throughout her appearance in Yellowstone, Beths mother, Evelyn Dutton was tough on her. Jamie helped Beth get pregnant when she was 15. Snowflakes are complainers and have an entitlement complex. Montana women are known for being tough, because of survival. Home of the Daily and Sunday Express. Yes, Beth Dutton wears a wig in Yellowstone. Im not a horse expert, but ive been around them a fair amount. Jamies biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. However, she was also fiercely independent and stubborn, which led to some tension between her and John. The beginning of episode three of the first season of Yellowstone brings us our first flashback, during which we learn how Beth developed that chip on her shoulder, and boy is it ever a doozy. Her mothers coldness towards her while dying and her passing at Beths young age has caused Beth lasting trauma. Instead of comforting or reassuring Beth, Evelyn immediately blames Beth for spooking her horse due to Beth's handling (or lack thereof) of her horse. Some of it got passed off as tough love and the boys got some of that too. Despite having a chance to clarify that Beths sterility is due to tubal ligation, it seems to have doubled down on the implausible take that Beth had a full hysterectomy. Who is Melanie Olmstead and Why Did Yellowstone Honor Her? Cue the only other living soul as lost, hurt, and lonely as Beth her soulmate, Rip Wheeler. Evelyn . But we see flashbacks mostly from beths perspective which taints the memory. This has huge implications. Not too long ago, my grandpa (who is approaching 80) said it was time for my daughter's to start barrel racing. She feels guilty about the accident and, at one point, even believes that she killed her mother by being scared when they went horseback riding that time. A horse is only scared of what youre scared of youre scared of everything. The girl with the baby in Yellowstone was Christina (Katherine Cunningham), Jamies sometime-lover in Season 2. Kayce had a son named Tate who was Jamies nephew. For example, when the horse fell on her and she was seriously injured, Evelyn told Kayce that it was her fault if she died. Dreamer. Why did she even blame her for falling off? Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) is the wife of John Dutton III who passed away in a horseback riding accident when her children were young. Lee Dutton may not be in the family photo because he is the one who took it. Beth is mean due to a mixture of many tragic layers, further amplified by her ongoing fury regarding her most unquenched desire. I do feel bad for this whole families tragedy due to the death of their mother & wife ! She saw weakness when Beth was cramping, and then learning to ride with her brothers. One theory suggests that Beth's hatred for Jamie is due to an unhealthy sibling rivalry that dates back to early in their lives. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Beth Dutton received her scar on her face during an attack orchestrated by the Beck brothers. GB News host moans as she rips into Meghan and Harry over racism row, GB News host laughs as Ann Widdecome brands woke culture 'dangerous', Michael Parkinson breaks down in tears as he reflects on his career, Yellowstone season 4: Real reason Evelyn hates Beth 'exposed' in spin-off clue, Yellowstone: Beth's mother was killed in a tragic accident, Naga Munchetty shut down by MP in Afghan evacuation debate, Yellowstone: Season four could feature more insight into Beth's past, Yellowstone: Tim McGraw and Faith Hill will star in the new spin-off, Money Heist season 5 theories: Rios death sealed in throwback clue, The Walking Dead: Showrunner opens up on dark final season, Below Decks Captain Lee addresses season 9 disappearance, GMB fury as Marine Commando in tears after being 'cut off' in Kabul, BBC host apologises as guest breaks down over Afghanistan crisis. She still never rode again, really. This rather outlandish theory proposes Evelyn harboured secret feelings for Beths intermittent boyfriend and Johns surrogate son, Rip. It's no secret that Beth hates Jamie with a fiery passion, and after he took her to get an abortion at a young age that resulted in her permanent infertility, she may have every right to be. Evelyn Dutton. Redditor iheartsev agrees that Beths mother seemed way too nasty b****y to her during that last ride with Kayce and Beth. What other consequences Evelyns death has for the rest of the family remains to be seen. He is the biological son of John Dutton. Let's recap: In true Dutton fashion, the family John, Beth, and Kayce ended the episode with dinner at the ranch house. The late Evelyn has an important talk with Beth that shapes her daughter forever. Why Did Yellowstone Pay Tribute to John Prine and Who is He? Evelyn may have been trying to push Beth out of her comfort zone in order to help her become more confident. Evelyn's death also had a huge impact on John. Costner has seven children, but not Reilly. Evelyn then apologizes to her in advance, saying she will hate everything thats about to happen to her. Yes, Evelyn Dutton had a sister. Categories . However, he uses his Machiavellian mind to push past it and rationalize signing Beth up for the abortion and the subsequent sterilization. Who knows. She lost her job when the share holders for the bank demanded her removal. So sad. The Dutton sibling's . The appearances of Evelyn we see in Yellowstone are in flashbacks and photos shown of her. The loss of John Dutton's wife affects him in a big way in 'Yellowstone'. The rest of Yellowstone Season 5 could have the answer to that and if Beth can soften her mean streak. He served as a livestock agent and was set to take over the ranch for his father, John Dutton III. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. She has yet to realize her revenge against Jamie, a brother she once loved and trusted and for whom her hatred now burns hotter than a thousand infernos. One perceptive Yellowstone enthusiast thinks theyve finally cracked why Beths mother Evelyn Dutton (Gretchen Mol) treated her so poorly in the shows flashbacks. There, they meet a young Beth Dutton, who is uncertain of herself, sensitive, and a bit lost. Beth went to get help while a young Kayce tried everything . He never has been fully able to recover from her tragic death. Why did Jon and Evelyn Dutton adopt Jamie? It seems she is blaming herself for everything that happened that day. This theory could be too much for some viewers to wrap their heads around, but they can tune into the new series this December to find out whether or not it holds water. Beths mom wanted to toughen her up. Nope. Learn More. why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth. and Im sorry in advance for doing it. He has to keep John from finding out that Beth is pregnant and keep John from killing Rip if that truth were to surface. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. No one other than Monica has dared to dig deeper. Unfortunately, details about the upcoming series are sparse, so this fans claims the Duttons originally hailed from the Salem of the infamous witch trials are currently unsubstantiated. While all the siblings deal with the trauma of losing their mother at a young age, Beth is the one who feels the guilt. Her immediate impulse upon seeing a woman she doesn't know in nothing but one of her father's shirts (the television world's way of showing that a woman has just had sex) is to threaten her with a. Its not an advisable emotional strategy at all, but its the reality of the character. At one point, Beth believes that she killed her mom by being scared.. Rips public record was erased for Johns protection. The son of a ranch owner and his wife is married to another woman. So I just binged the first three seasons and have a few questions, begins Yellowstone fan tomcookgod over on Reddit. 'The Father Who Moves Mountains' Ending, Explained: Let's Discuss, 'Mystery 101' Update: Why I'm Worried About The Next Movie, 'Money Heist' Series Ending, Explained: How Season 5 Finished It All. However, her life forever changed on March 30, 1997. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Snowflakes is a term used by local Montanan's to describe people not from Montana. Though, there are some who are excellent at being abusive behind closed doors and different when others are observing. She thinks that a day might come when he discovers or she will tell him. Not crazy. With Jamie giving her a lift home when she was drunk series 1, "you have to see them when they die, my mom didn't love me not one bit in her eyes" or words to that effect when she fell off the horse. The appearances of Evelyn we see in Yellowstone are in flashbacks and photos shown of her. It might seem obvious to others. The show has plenty of enigmatic characters, and one that has fans debating is Evelyn Dutton, John Duttons wife. This supposed matriarch that John has been pining away for or Beth cant get over, sure seemed kind of insensitive and spiteful. But he will be mad at Jamie. Jamie came up with the idea of having Beth get an abortion at the Indian Reservation in order to keep this from John. Beths final moments with her mother were not filled with forgiveness or comfort. Fans will have to wait and see if any more flashbacks explain their strained relationship any further, but a new theory has proposed the upcoming Yellowstone prequel could also reveal more. Lucille Ball told everyone in Hollywood, when she first arrived, that she was from Butte, Montana. Monica Long was married to Kayce and they had a son named Tate. We owe you nothing. When the horse fell on her she straight up told a 10 year old that it was her fault if she died, while basically saying that Kayce was the child she loved most. Jamie does not realize until he is signing Beth up for the procedure that for her to get an abortion there, she must also get sterilized. But as the series has moved along, her hate for him continues to grow more and more intense, and some fans think she's gone overboard. The oldest Dutton sibling (Dave Annabel) died in season 1 during a dispute over cattle. She was a strong, independent woman who loved her family and her horses. Yellowstone Season 2. The next time we see her, Beth has just "entered womanhood" and she seems better toward Beth if not begrudgingly. In Yellowstone Season 3, John finally learns the truth amid Beth and Jamies ever-escalating feud. Which is what I think Evelyn had to do herself. Since moving to the Dutton ranch with Kayce, Monica has had to deal with a number of traumas, the most recent of which was the attack in the season 4 premiere. It turns out she was hard on her because she wanted to toughen her up. I have to turn you into the man most men will never be. In the end, it all makes for excellent fictional drama. That's why we do it. Jamie may be more estranged than ever from the Duttons, but he has something Beth never can a biological child. Before the tragic incident, Beth was nervous while on her horse, causing it to get spooked. Beth (Kelly Reilly) is the only daughter of the Dutton family, and she helps run the family's business operations. How could that not turn a switch off in Beth? Maybe she was just a cunt. Jamie has two brothers and a sister, and he is the son of John and Evelyn Dutton. She only makes four appearances in Yellowstone, as she passed away in 1997 when her children were still young. The story goes that. As a kid, Beth had a relatively normal upbringing though her mom was often hard on her. why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth A past as broken as that of the Dutton family would scar anyone for life. But after being treated like youre weaker long enough, youll start to believe it, too, Evelyn continues. According to his official website, he was a former Navy Seal who was decorated with two Presidential Unit Citations and two Joint Meritorious Unit Awards. In future flashbacks, we know young Beth fools around with Rip, but we don't get a lot more of Evelyn Dutton in the series (thus far). Though Evelyn was tough on Beth, she still considers her mother the spine of the family., John once told Kayce that Im half the man without her. RELATED: Did John Dutton Die in the Yellowstone Series? In an interview with actress Kelly Reily, who portrays Beth, she states that We get to see this very pure young girl go through such a trauma. That scene brought to mind that when we were kids, my 6 year old sister was on a Male horse that ran between a female horse who was spooked and tethered to a post in an arena. Beth is being raised on a really large Montana ranch. Yeah but Beth had zero confidence riding the horse. Spooked or not, I think thats what the scene was meant to invoke. I Lov this series Yellowstone its actresses & actors! Evelyn Dutton existed in flashbacks STRICTLY for Beth's story, and no other reason at all. Yellowstone has not even allowed Beth to express how she felt beyond her righteous anger over being infertile. Her mother passed away when she was young. Beth married her boyfriend, Rip Wheeler, in an impromptu ceremony as she prepared to confront Jamie. Why does Evelyn Dutton hate Beth? She fought back but didnt know what to do. Now, an extreme event like that is just that, a freak event. Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. You should try zoomba. You can unsubscribe at any time. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. But I look back and I know my mother was right. Fan Mi-Ofelia takes it a step further by noting they couldnt stand Evelyn from the very beginning and had no empathy for her when she fell off her horse. 15 Facts About Evelyn Dutton Yellowstone, 14 Facts About Jacob Elordi Movies And Tv Shows. Conversely, opting to make it all about the other reason Beth is so mean. Theyve Had an Inappropriate Relationship For Months, How Black Creators Can Expand Their Network with LinkedIn. John has tasked her with . DON'T MISS:Money Heist season 5 theories: Rios death sealed in throwback clue[THEORY]The Walking Dead: Showrunner opens up on dark final season[INTERVIEW]Below Decks Captain Lee addresses season 9 disappearance[INSIGHT]. Her father too lives with this headache & loneliness. In a previous episode of Yellowstone, Jamie took Beth to an abortion that ended with her being forced to have sex. H-O-M-E.org is a website that provides information and entertainment to help you live your best life!Our mission is to provide our readers with entertainment and knowledge about their favorite subjects while staying up to date on all the latest trends in popular culture. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. Beth holds a professional profile in banking while being fiercely committed to family proving time and time again she is loyal only to the ones she loves. William was born in Denton, TX and currently resides in Austin. totino's snack mix discontinued; Such a sad & heartbreaking story for the whole family especially for Beth who was so young ! She had to grapple with the emotional and physical impact of losing a huge part of herself, and Beth endured that alone. Bethany 'Beth' Dutton-Wheeler is a main character on Yellowstone and John Dutton's daughter. Doer. Though Beth is able to find her father and bring him to her injured mother, they are too late. Home; Work; Process; About; CV; Contact; Home; Work; Process; About; CV; Contact For starters, she only made four appearances in the show, all of which were in a flashback or simply photos of her shown during the show. While Evelyn comforts Beth after she becomes a woman, she also gives a harsh speech about what it means to be a woman in the world. It was a time when Beth was a skittish young teen with no self-confidence , which irritated her mother Evelyn (Gretchen Mol). Did John Dutton Die in the Yellowstone Series? Seemingly, their two supernatural connections would have linked them together, were it not for Beths interference. Naturally, fans of the show have wondered why Beth remains hostile towards her brother. When Jamie was three months old, John and Evelyn Dutton adopted him. Maybe there was real hate. How did a teenage Beth manage the hormonal changes of a hysterectomy? But Beth got a raw deal from mommy dearest, one Reddit user writes in response to the original poster. The Dutton family hates Jamie because he is not a true Dutton. Tate was kidnapped at the end of the second season. Hollywood Life, Latest Hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News. After his wife and son have had traumatic moments at the ranch, Kayce decides to move his family away. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Some fans, however, still dont think enough has been said on the matter. Throughout Yellowstone, Beth struggles to deal with the death of her mother. Amato has over 100 credits to his name as an actor. She is the mother of Lee, Beth and Kayce Dutton. She also had 3 sons, and a husband, and there's no indication at all that they didn't feel loved by her. Rips bloodline of the, In Old Norse, seir [is] a type of magic practised in Norse society during the Late Scandinavian Iron Age., The practice of seir is believed to be a form of magic relating to both the telling and shaping of the future. She made her aware that she was entering a world dominated by men. He was a hardworking man who was always looking out for his family and the community. They are the eldest son and daughter of the Dutton family, respectively. Why does Beth hate Jamie: Fan theories. The actress told TV Line that the fear of losing her secret is too great. The show has told us that she pushed Rip away and engaged in every endeavor to do that. Johns sister is played byAudie Rick. Maybe it was the writers fault, thats what I assume, but that scene did not fit with Evelyns previous dealings with Beth, they add. I am re-watching Season 1, and when we are introduced to Evelyn Dutton (John's wife), she is downright hostile to Beth (horse riding scene). Beth had to deal with a sudden and enormous change in her physiology. I think people narrow Evelyn Dutton down to just Beth, and there is clearly a much bigger story then that. When Yellowstone explains how the Duttons were shaped by their matriarch, Evelyn Dutton, it takes viewers back to the past. Does Tate Dutton Fail to Escape Deaths Grasp in Yellowstone? *Eclectic Pop's social media links are below* , The ending chapter of the 365 Days movie trilogy arrived on Netflix with the adaptation of Book 3, The Father Who Moves Mountains (Tata Muta Muntii) is a Romanian film currently streaming on Net, When is the next Mystery 101 movie premiering? However, it is Jamies latest betrayal of their father that gives Beth the green light to potentially realize her darkest dream. When viewers glimpse Beth in flashbacks during Season 1, it is obvious that Beth was not born with her claws out. Not every character on the show has really done much work on their self. Yellowstone plot hole: Why doesn't the Dutton's home have security? Second - John Dutton Sr. Third - John Dutton Jr. Fourth - John Dutton III. As Yellowstone has moved forward, it has distanced itself from this part of Beths backstory. When Beths riding scares the horse, it has a domino effect. and no they did not explain it, except to say that the condo developer did it, i think. However, her appearances have been relegated to flashbacks as. This event left Beth with a great deal of guilt and trauma, which she repressed for many years. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. They were raised on the same ranch. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The details of the accident are not clear, but it seems that Beths horse became spooked and threw her off, causing her mother to be fatally crushed by another horse. However, fans have another outlook on the relationship.